Auto-renewal itself is legal — it's how hard the provider makes you fight to cancel it that the law is increasingly cracking down on.
Yes, if you agreed to it when you signed up — auto-renewal itself isn't the problem in either country. What's changing fast, and what actually matters for your rights, is how the renewal has to be disclosed and how easy the provider must make it for you to cancel. California's AB 2863, in force since July 2025, is currently the toughest law in the country on this specifically: it requires an easy online cancellation option and bans "obstructing or delaying" your ability to cancel, even though it does still let providers offer you a discount to stay, as long as a clear cancel button is right there too. Other US states have weaker or no equivalent rules, and the UK relies on general contract fairness principles rather than one dedicated statute.
| United States | United Kingdom | |
|---|---|---|
| Dedicated auto-renewal statute | Varies significantly by state — California's AB 2863 (effective 1 July 2025) is the strongest and most detailed; many other states have weaker or no equivalent | No single dedicated statute — governed by general contract fairness under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 and Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 |
| Cancellation method requirement | Under California's law: must be as easy as signing up, available online, and cannot be obstructed or delayed | No specific "one-click" mandate, but making cancellation unreasonably difficult can be challenged as an unfair term |
| Free trial → paid conversion | California's law explicitly covers free-to-pay conversions, requiring clear disclosure that a charge will follow | Similar expectation under general consumer protection principles — a silent conversion from free to paid without clear notice is vulnerable to challenge |
| Renewal reminder requirement | California requires annual renewal reminders detailing the service, charge amount, and how to cancel, sent through the same medium used to sign up | No universal statutory reminder requirement, though failing to notify before a renewal charge strengthens a dispute under general fairness principles |
| Retention offers during cancellation | Permitted under California's law, provided a clear, immediately effective cancel button is displayed on the same page | Not specifically regulated, but an aggressive retention flow that effectively blocks cancellation could be challenged as an unfair practice |
California's law is worth knowing about even if you're not in California, because many national or global course platforms update their cancellation flow for all users once they've had to build compliant systems for California specifically — this is a common pattern where a strict state law effectively raises the baseline experience everywhere. If a course provider's cancellation process feels deliberately convoluted, it's worth checking whether they're already required to do better somewhere.
If the sign-up flow clearly disclosed the recurring charge, its amount, and frequency, this is generally an enforceable term in both countries.
If you're in California, this specifically may not comply with AB 2863's requirement that cancellation be at least as easy as signing up. Elsewhere in the US, this depends on your specific state, but it's exactly the kind of "dark pattern" regulators nationally and in the UK have been targeting.
Under California law, this is explicitly covered and requires clear advance disclosure. In the UK, a silent conversion without adequate notice is a strong candidate for an unfair-term challenge, even without a dedicated statute matching California's specificity.
California requires an annual reminder with the charge amount and cancellation method. Most other US states and the UK don't have an equivalent blanket requirement — this is one of the areas where your protection genuinely depends heavily on where you live.
An online account settings page with a clearly visible "Cancel Subscription" button that immediately ends the recurring charge, optionally alongside (not instead of) a discount offer.
Requiring a phone call during limited business hours, multiple confirmation screens designed to discourage cancellation, or burying the cancel option behind account settings that don't clearly lead to it.
Use our Subscription Cancellation Demand Letter generator to formally request cancellation and dispute any obstruction.
Explore Training & Education tools →