Can a company increase my subscription price without my consent?
In most states, they just need to warn you — your consent is assumed unless you cancel in time.
In most of the US, a company doesn't need your active consent to raise a subscription price — it needs to give you advance notice, and your continued use after that notice is treated as your consent. That's the general model. California is more specific: businesses must notify you of any fee change at least 7 days and no more than 30 days before it takes effect, with clear cancellation information included. New York has moved further, requiring clearer disclosure and consent specifically around price increases under its amended rules.
Notice vs. consent — the distinction that matters
These are two different legal standards, and most states only require the weaker one:
- Notice-based (most states): the company must tell you the price is going up and when — your "consent" is implied by not cancelling before the new price takes effect.
- Consent-based (fewer states, stronger protection): the company must get you to actively agree to the new price, not just passively not object to it.
California's rule sits closer to the notice-based model but with a specific, enforced timeframe (7-30 days). New York's amended rules push further toward requiring genuine consent for price increases specifically, which is a meaningfully stronger standard.
What California specifically requires
Under the amended Automatic Renewal Law (in force since July 1, 2025):
- Notice of any fee change must be given at least 7 days and no more than 30 days before the new price takes effect
- The notice must be in a form the consumer can retain (email, not just an in-app banner that disappears)
- It must include clear information on how to cancel before the new price applies
If you're in California and got charged a higher price with no notice in that window, that's a specific, citable violation — not just a complaint about being surprised.
What to do if you weren't warned
- Check your email (including spam/promotions folders) for any notice you might have missed — companies sometimes did send it, just not somewhere you noticed.
- If you're in California and genuinely received no notice in the 7-30 day window, contact the company directly citing the Automatic Renewal Law and request a refund of the difference or cancellation with a refund of the increased charge.
- In states without a specific notice-timing law, you still have a general good-faith argument if the increase was disclosed nowhere findable — this is weaker legally but often works as a customer-service escalation.
- If the company won't resolve it, dispute the increased portion of the charge with your card issuer, explaining that you weren't given adequate notice.
- Cancel going forward if you don't want to risk it happening again with the next renewal.
Related questions
Official sources
Price went up without warning?
Use Kibbo's Subscriptions & Services tools to draft a refund request citing the exact notice requirement that applies to you.
Explore Subscriptions & Services tools →